The earliest connection to the Geneva Tool Co. indicates that a man named Norman S. Caswell, a maker of scythes, handles and such sold his goods from the back of his wagon as early as 1849. In 1854 he formed a partnership with O. H. and J. H Price and worked in a building located on the south ridge of Geneva, Ohio. By 1868 the company was doing well enough to justify the forming of a stock company which was then named the Geneva Tool Co. In addition to manufacturing some of their goods, the company may have applied labels and markings to the goods they resold that had been obtained from other sources.
Axes bearing the Geneva Tool Co. name seem to have been advertised more in Canadian Catalogs than catalogs from US concerns. Axes with the company name appeared in the 1901 Caverhill, Learmont & Co. catalog as well as magazine advertisements for Caverhill, Learmont & Co. during the first two decades of the twentieth century. Caverhill, Learmont & Co. was a Canadian company located in Montreal, Quebec.
The Geneva Tool Co. was one of the sixteen companies that joined together to form the American Fork & Hoe Co. in 1902. Many of the brands owned by those sixteen companies continued to be made and distributed. The axe brands may have been gradually replaced by the brands associated with the Kelly Axe & Tool Works, a division of American Fork & Hoe Co. (later to become True Temper) The Geneva line labels may also have been continued to satisfy marketing arrangements involving distributors in Canada.